What exactly these angelic cherubs are up to in this etching will remain a mystery to Slack Investor, but he would say that looking at things from a distance is a worthwhile trait in the stock market world. Slack Investor is currently in Europe on holiday and the geographical distance and time zone shift have helped him take more of a holiday from the markets … and just let them get on with it – without interference!
Take the long view
There are some scary headlines and plenty of volatility on the stock markets with worries about inflation and international bank collapses. Slack Investor will just pass on some sage advice. Here is the secret to being a good investor …
Don’t get caught up in what happens in three months, six months, or 12 months. It’s about the next five to seven years.
Paul Taylor is no mug … his Australian Equities Fund is of the managed fund variety and, despite a slug of 0.85% p.a. in management fees, his fund has kept pace or slightly bettered the performance of the ASX 200 Accumulation index over the 5 and 10-yr periods. Even though the managers of the fund appear to know what they are doing, the difficulty of beating index funds over every time period is shown by the negative relative performance over 1 and 7-yrs.
Now, Slack Investor completely agrees with Mr Taylor, when investing in equities (shares), you should be locking them up for at least 5 years so that any volatility will be swamped by the beautiful long-term march of increasing value for Australian and International Shares. See the latest Vanguard Long Term Chart to see what I mean.
Slack Investor is still “pretend hurting” from his own last year’s (FY22) annual Slack performance (-14.3%). However, he realises his 5-yr and 10-yr performance is the critical measure for his Slack Fund. As these returns p.a. (13.5% (5-yr) and 15.2% (10-yr), are comfortably above benchmarks, I have reconciled the poor one year figures as just part of the volatility of owning mostly growth shares.
Contribute regularly to your savings
Whether adding to your super, or investment savings, the best way to do this is to add regularly, without even thinking about it. Set up an automatic personal deduction from your salary to your super – or automatically contribute to your savings through a vehicle that is in sync with your risk tolerances (e.g. Stockspot, Pearler).
As my super was accumulating, it was mostly in broad-based index funds (Australian and International). My other investments were mostly in individual companies.
While it’s possible to beat index funds, it’s not easy to do over the long run … and as it isn’t worthwhile for most of us to try.
Slack Investor has some exposure to index-type ETF’s but continues to dabble in individual companies. Despite the above warning, Slack Investor will continue to “have a crack” at stock selection and portfolio management – but only while his long-term performance still stands up.
Slack Investor has blogged about financial advice before – and although an advocate of trying to do as much as you can by researching finance world yourself, it can be a very difficult journey to be across all the fields of saving, mortgages, investment loans, insurance, superannuation, taxation, and investment.
Most people want financial advice but the problem is that it is so expensive. MoneySmart.gov.au outline a case study where “Rhett” has $400 000 to invest – He might be hit with fees of $13 600 in his first year of advice . These fees include a Statement of Advice and Insurance premiums and layers of platform and investment advice fees.
Where to invest your money is the easiest thing to sort out for yourself – with the key words being diversification and low fees. There are cost-effective ways of investing in a diversified way that will suit your risk tolerance without involving a financial advisor (e.g. Stockspot, Pearler). But some people (Not Slack Investor Readers!) need a trigger to just start investing. Finance world is much more complex than just investing your money. Slack Investor can see the need for finance professionals
Things a Financial Advisor might tell you
Firstlinks have trawled the data to determine the most recommended strategy used by financial advisers – the most common of these are listed below.
Let’s just have a look at some of these in more detail.
Rollover Your Super – “Rolling Over” your superannuation is just a way of describing the transfer of your “protected” super into another protected super fund. Slack Investor readers will be all over this one – Of course it makes sense to put all of your super with one provider to avoid multiple administration fees. Combine your super into one fund – preferably an industry fund (lowest fees) with a good 5-10 yr performance record.
Retain Your Super – This is again good advice for the long-term accumulators of wealth. Unless under extreme hardship, resist all attempts for early access to your super. During the COVID-19 outbreak, $4 billion was paid out to 456,000 people under the early super access scheme. This would have helped distressed businesses and individuals in the short-term but may not have been a great idea in the longer term.
Super Contributions – This is a more complicated area and, it might be good to have advice on when, and by how much ,you should boost your super contributions above those which are compulsory. This is tricky when you have competing loads on your take-home pay (Family, Mortgage, etc). Slack Investor was big on maximizing his super contributions once he had a firm grip on his home mortgage.
Apply for Insurance – When you have a family or debts (home loan?) to cover, life and disability insurance is a good idea. You don’t need an advisor to tell you this. Insurance through your super fund is usually the most cost effective way to do this.
Estate and Aged Care Planning – This area is really complicated for the layman. Professional Advice, or much research, needed.
Commence, Rollover, Retain Pension – You may need advice here if planning to mix aged-pension and super to fund retirement. If there are no aged-pension issues, Slack Investor believes that it is best to start an account pension (from your super) as soon as possible and re-contribute any surplus funds as non-concessional contributions.
Commence, Rebalance Investment – An old truth – Best time to start investing? 20 years ago. Next best time to start investing? Now! Rebalancing can be done automatically with cost-effective platforms e.g., Vanguard Super, Stockspot.
What Types of advice Do You Really Need?
The current financial advice system is complicated by well-meaning regulations that are in dire need of reform. In 2022, the Australian Treasury provided a consultation paper seeking feedback on changes to the regulatory regime that would allow financial advice on specific matters without the obligation that the advisor should know everything about your financial situation – No need for the expensive Statement of Advice (SOA).
Ideally, in a future world, you could get advice at various stages in your life from finance professionals at an hourly rate – perhaps in the same way you would consult a medical specialist about a problem. For Instance
Early/Mid-Career Advice: Am I on track with my savings, super contributions and retirement plan? What strategies should I employ to achieve my goals?
Pre-Retirement: Am I ready? Taxation Issues? Aged-pension/Super mix?
Estate and Aged Care Planning: Complicated – Many issues to discuss here.
Alternatively, you could just turn your financial future into a hobby (Like Slack Investor did), and use the internet and books to educate yourself.
May 2023 – End of Month Update
Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100. It was a dreary month for the Slack Investor followed markets. The ASX 200 performed poorly this month – down 3.0%, and the FTSE 100 even worse – down 5.4%. The S&P 500 was flat (+0.2%) for the month.
In this month of turmoil for stock indexes, the Slack Portfolio did quite well. This is because it is heavy with technology stocks that are having a moment in the sunshine. The Nasdaq 100 index was up 7.7% for the month of May.
All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).
A bloke with a barrow of mutilated currency circa 1910
Every quarter, the economic boffins at ASFA (Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia go to the trouble of crunching the numbers on what yearly income they think is required for a “comfortable retirement”. They assume that the retirees own their own home outright and are relatively healthy. In one year, due to inflation, the comfortable retirement amount has increased by 7.6% , or $4920, to $69,691 for a couple (Dec 2022 ).
Comfortable lifestyle (p. a.)
Modest lifestyle (p. a.)
Couple $69,691
Couple $45,106
Single $49,462
Single $31,323
ASFA calculated annual retirement requirements for those aged 65-84 (December quarter 2022) for both “comfortable” and “modest” lifestyles
ASFA’s calculations are very detailed, but notably these annual incomes do not include any overseas travel – depending on your accommodation standards and length of journey, this could easily require another $20K.
Their latest December 2022 report notes that price rises have occurred for most spending categories. In the last four quarters,
Food rose by 9.2%
Bread 13.4%
Meat and seafoods 8.2%
Milk 17.9%
Oils and fats 20.8%
Gas 17.4%
Electricity 11.7%
Household appliances 10.2%
Automotive fuel 13.2%
Domestic travel and accommodation 19.8%
International travel and accommodation 15.9%
ASFA also helpfully calculate a lump sum that you will need to supply this income – with the assumptions that the lump sum is invested (earning more than the cpi) and will be fully spent by age 92. Let’s aim high and just concentrate on the comfortable retirement – the “modest” retirement lump sum amounts are much lower (around $100K) as they assume supplementation from the aged pension.
Savings required for a comfortable retirement at age 67
Couple $690,000
Single $595,000
ASFA calculated lump sum t requirements for those aged 65-84 (December quarter 2022) for a “comfortable” lifestyle
How to Cope with Inflation
There is just one simple way – you must be invested in appreciating assets that keep pace (or exceed inflation). Appreciating assets tend to go up in value over time. This is pretty vague, but if you are unsure about an asset, try and find a price chart over a 10-yr to 20-yr period. If it is going up, it is probably an appreciating asset.
You will always need some amount in cash for day to day requirements and to ride out any investment cycles without the need to cash in your investments at a low point in the cycle.
Knowing the difference between an appreciating and a depreciating asset (e,g cars, furniture, technology equipment, boats, etc) was an important step in Slack Investor’s investing life. I can still remember the day my father gave me “the talk”, that it was OK to borrow money for appreciating assets – I think he was pushing me in the direction of real estate at the time. However, I was not to borrow for a depreciation one i.e. a car, or consumer goods – assets that lose value when you walk out of the shop!
Appreciating Assets
Below is a (not exhaustive) list of appreciating assets. I have left out cryptocurrency deliberately as it has only been traded since 2010, and it is not established yet that it is a long-term appreciating asset.
List of appreciating assets:
Real estate
Real estate investment trust (REIT)
Stocks (Shares) and ETF’s
Bonds
Commodities and Precious Metals
Private Equity
Term Deposits and Savings Accounts
Collectibles e.g. Art
Term deposits and savings accounts might keep pace with inflation (if your lucky!) – but generally do not grow faster than inflation. Slack investor will write about why owning your own home and investing in Stocks (Shares) and ETF’s are his favourite appreciating assets in a later post.
Slack Investor loves a good story – whether its true or not! I like the owning of stocks and I also admire anyone who can stick to their vows. All of this seems to intersect with the story of the Coppock Curve – a technical indicator that can be mapped on stock price charts that has a great track record for showing when the market has reached the “bottom” of a cycle.
When I first started to think a bit more seriously about financial things, I was going to an evening investment class in Townsville. The class was held by a personal Slack Investor Hero, Robbie Fuller, who put on these classes for no personal gain … he just wanted to educate people about the opportunities that lay waiting in the stock market. Robbie would teach us about fundamental analysis (trying to measure the intrinsic value of a stock) and technical analysis (charts and trends). There was always a particular beauty when fundamental and technical information aligned about a company.
The class was usually a lot of fun, but I remember a time around 2011 when the markets were going through a bit of a lacklustre period and we had all had a few recent losing trades – there was just not much excitement about stocks.
Robbie came bounding in one evening after 31 July 2012 with the news that the Coppock Indicator had just turned … it was a sign that “good things will happen”- He was right – It was the start of a 3-yr period where the Australian market was mostly rising. It is much easier to trade when the “tide is coming in”.
The Coppock Curve is a “smoothed” momentum indicator developed by the economist Edwin “Sedge” Coppock and published in in a 1962 issue of Barron’s. It all started when he was commissioned by the Episcopal Church to find long-term investment opportunities for the Church fund.
According to the legend, he asked a group of nuns (or bishops!) how long it took the bereaved to “recover” from their grief. The answer was 11 to 14 months. He took the radical step of thinking that something similar might happen in stock markets after a market high and subsequent downtrend. He assumed that because markets are motivated by emotion, they might be ready to “move on” after a period of 11-14 months of “grief”.
“Crowds do too much too soon”, he wrote. “They overdo. When they get an urge to speculate, their concerted demand forces prices up at a rate far greater than the growth of the company into which they are buying. Likewise, when they liquidate holdings or make short sales during a panicky decline, they ignore basic economic facts. They overdo because they are motivated by emotion rather than reason.”
The Coppock Indicator has had an incredible track record in signalling the end of a “bear market”. The signal (Green Arrow) is triggered when the indicator (shown in the lower screen below) bottoms from under the zero line and then slopes upwards.
Monthly chart of the ASX 200 together with the Coppock Indicator below. The green arrows show the “bottom of the market” predictions using the Coppock Indicator. The red arrows show a possible time to sell – Click the chart for better resolution – Incrediblecharts.com
The indicator gives buy signals very rarely, only 6 times in the past 30 years for the ASX 200. But it has just given another one, signalling a buy for the ASX 200. The maths of the curve is a little complex, but it looks for the next uptrend after the market establishes a high and then goes through a 11-14-month “greiving” period.
Is Coppock’s Bollocks?
There is no perfect trading indicator. Coppock designed his indicator to try to establish a “bottom of the market” buy signal to identify long term investment opportunities. He didn’t try to use it as a selling tool. However, there is a trading strategy that uses this indicator after a BUY signal.
SELL when the Coppock Curve takes its first downwards trajectory OR,
SELL when the Coppock Curve falls below zero
I have trialled both methods and the strongest gain (p.a) results were with the first method. I have marked these sell signals on the chart above with red arrows and tabulated the gain results below.
COPPOCK CYCLE
BUY DATE
ASX200
SELL DATE
ASX200
GAIN
PERIOD(yr)
GAIN (p.a.)
1
31-May-95
1981
28-Jan-96
2171
10%
0.66
14.5%
2
30-May-03
3010
29-Apr-05
3983
32%
1.91
16.9%
3
29-May-09
3817
30-Jun-10
4493
18%
1.09
16.3%
4
31-Jul-12
4269
28-Jun-13
4802
12%
0.91
13.7%
5
31-May-16
5378
30-Jun-17
5721
6%
1.08
5.9%
6
30-Nov-20
6517
29-Oct-21
7323
12%
0.91
13.5%
31-Jan-23
7400?
?
?
?
?
?
Slack Investor uses Incredible Charts to do all his charting … but their indicator screen can get complicated. To easily follow the Coppock Indicator on any stock, just use the free, but great, StockCharts and put in the same chart attributes below.
ASX 200 Chart from StockCharts – showing stock price on top and the Coppock Curve below.
However, looking at the chart history of this indicator … and the GAIN results in the above table, this is not advice, but now looks like a good time to get into the Australian market. Although, officially, the Coppock results are based on the end of month data. In addition, using Slack Investor’s CAPE valuation method, at the end of December 2022 the ASX 200 was “fairly valued”.
A 1999 extract from The Sydney Morning Herald showing a 13-yr old Chris Brycki – smartcompany.com.au
Slack Investor will admit to being less than young … but I am still capable of being a “Fan boy” when I see something impressive happening in the financial world.
After a series of schoolboy stock picking successes – winning the ASX’s Share Game a remarkable 3 times and, at university, he entered the JP Morgan Trading Competition, which he also won several times. The talented Chris “the Brick” Brycki, launched into a career with stockbrokers and financial houses. After a while, he started to question the long term performance of fund managers.
“… The problem is that over time, even by being right, the value added is not big enough to counteract the 1% fee that a lot of these fund managers charge.”
Chris founded Stockspot in 2013 as an alternative way to invest. Their Robo Advice model offers a low-cost automated alternative to traditional fund managers and advisors. After a simple online survey to determine your investing stage and risk tolerance, an investment portfolio type is recommended to you.
Chris (and Stockspot) have come up with the breathtakingly simple, yet genius (Both Slack Investor and Donald Trump have a loose definition of genius), strategy. After researching thousands of ETF’s and, based on exposure, performance and low fee costs – Stockspot has selected just 5 of them as the building blocks for a range of different portfolios. The portfolios are based on risk tolerance, financial situation and the investor’s appetite for volatility. The five component ETF’s are in Australian Shares (VAS), Global Shares (IOO), Emerging Global Markets(IEM), Australian Fixed Income (IAF), and Physical Gold (GOLD).
The five ETF’s that Stockspot use to build their portfolios (1-yr Performance is to 13Oct 2022) – most of these ETF’s have a $500 minimum if you are investing directly.
It is best to disregard the above 1-yr performance – It has just been a bad year for most assets. The ETF management fees are low (depending on ETF complexity), there is good long term performance (Growth since Inception) and they have selected Physical Gold for inclusion.
Slack Investor does not naturally lean into Gold as it is a speculative, non-income producing asset. However, I might have to change my mind here. The reason Stockspot include Gold in all their portfolios is based upon historical data and the way gold tends to outperform in times of crisis. The results in this last year performance of +7.34% for Gold, speak for itself – as other asset classes flounder.
A chart showing relative risk and return (grey line) of a portfolio varying between 100% Australian Bonds and 100% Australian Shares. The Stockspot portfolios have historically yielded lower returns than 100% Australian Shares) – but only slightly in their most aggressive Topaz portfolio. Overall, through their diversification, the portfolios represent much lower risk.
5-yr annual performance (After Fees) – to 30 September 2022 – From Stockspot
There are fees involved for Stockspot to manage your money. For a balance of $200000, they amount to 0.66%. At first blush, these fees (on top of the ETF fees) sound a bit steep to Slack Investor. However, for all types of investors, with a time horizon of at least 3-5 years, for a stress-free place to put your money, this might be exactly what they are looking for. Stockspot do a tailor-made portfolio construction, all the re-balancing of assets and, they take care of all brokerage costs – Not Bad! They even have zero management fees for children accounts up to $10,000 (for under 18s) and the ability to dollar cost average with regular top-ups.
Stockspot does not earn fees from or have a commercial relationship with the ETFs we recommend. We don’t pay professionals for recommending our service to their clients.
Slack Investor can think of lots of situations where people would like a decision-free, low-fee, diverse investment that is designed to grow in the long term. Well done Chris Brycki (and Stockspot), for advancing the investing cause with particular attention to keeping the fees down … you are a Slack Investor Hero.
October 2022 – Mid-Month Update
Despite the above discussion, my small-scale market timing experiment continues until its projected end in 2024. My frustration with this experiment continues – as it often goes against one of Slack Investors firm beliefs. If you can avoid it – Do not sell an asset when it is undervalued. Using historical CAPE values, at the end of September 2022, the UK Index (FTSE 100) was 13% below its long term mean, the US Index (S&P 500) was 9% above its long term mean, and the Australian Index (S&P 500) was 7% below its long term mean.
At the end of September 2022, Slack Investor was on SELL ALERT for Australian index shares (ASX 200), the US Index (S&P 500) and the UK Index (FTSE 100). Each of them had broken through their monthly stop loss.
I have a “soft sell” approach when I gauge that the market is not too overvalued. I generally will not sell against the overall trend but monitor my index funds on a weekly basis once the monthly stop loss has been triggered.
Well … I can see no obvious up-trend at the end of the week for the US and UK marketsand will exit at the end of week price of 3583 for the S&P 500 and 6858 for the FTSE 100. I am still justhanging in with the ASX 200 as they had a strong finish to the week.
The Index pages and charts have been updated for the UK Index and US Index.
Extract from the 2022 Vanguard Index chart (Just the 2008-2022 portion) – the dollar values on the right are the results of investing $10000 in index funds in each asset class for 30 years (since July 1992). – Check out the full glory of the Vanguard 2022.PDF chart – Click for better resolution.
The lessons of long term investing
Every year Vanguard publish their performance data on each asset class. Slack Investor looks forward to this – as it demonstrates the powerful compounding that happens when the appreciating asset classes of Shares and Property are held for a long time (30 years). Although this Vanguard collection of data shows the volatility of asset values in the short term – it also also emphasizes the joys of holding and accumulating shares or property for long periods of time. These asset classes have steadily increased in value over the last 30 years. $10000 invested in Australian Shares in 1992 would have compounded to $131 413 in 2022, US Shares would have compounded to $182,376. Staying in Cash would have yielded $35 758.
Slack Investor says download and study this chart … and work towards getting some appreciating assets … accumulate, then hang on!
Financial year total returns (%) for the major asset classes
In the Vanguard 2022 table below, for each asset class the total annual returns are given and the best performing class for each year is shaded in blue … and the worst in pink. What stands out to Slack Investor is that is rare for and asset class to lead in annual returns (blue) for two years in a row – and there are years where the leading asset class (blue) becomes the worst performer (pink) in the next year. This drives home the often repeated sentence in the finance world.
Past performance is not a guarantee of future results – but 30 years of data talks loudly to Slack Investor.
Total returns for each asset class for the 30 years since 1992 – Check out the full glory of the Vanguard 2022.PDF – Click for better resolution.
This table highlights the benefits of diversification across asset classes for the long term investor. Each asset class might be the best performing (Blue shading), or the worst performing (Pink shading) for the year – and might dominate (or languish) for up to two years in a row. However, often a worst performing asset will show up as the best performing asset in the very next year – or vice versa.
Slack Investor is accepting of the negative returns for FY 2022 for most of the asset classes – and is concentrating on the 30-yr average long-term annual returns for holding shares and property of over 9% p.a.
When averaged over 30 years, the asset class and annual returns are : For AUST. SHARES 9.8%; INT’L SHARES 9.1%; U.S. SHARES 11.7%; LISTED PROPERTY 9.3%; and INT’L LISTED PROPERTY 10.7%; This compares with the average cash return of 4.4% p.a.
Slack Investor knows where he wants to be.
August 2022 – End of Month Update
Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100.
Inflation fears seemed to have spooked the overseas markets (S&P 500 -4.2 %, and the FTSE 100 -1.9%). The Australian stock market ended up pretty flat this month (ASX 200 +0 6%).
All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).
“When you can measure what you are speaking about, and express it in numbers, you know something about it. ”
Lord Kelvin (William Thomson, Mathematician and Physicist, 1824-1907)
Slack Investor reflects on a tough investing year. I have mostly “stuck to my guns” investing with growing companies that have an established earnings record and forward P/E ratios <50. There have been a few lapses (e.g. XRO) which had a forward PE ratio of about 100 when I bought it last financial year … and, I paid the price when the higher interest rates and threats of inflation caused a rapid change in valuation of most tech stocks.
I expect a bit of volatility in my mostly “growth” investment portfolio and I try to reassure myself that, despite the odd negative year in the Slack Investment Portfolio the Stable Income portfolio is doing its job and keeping Slack Investor with enough cash to keep things running. In the world markets, the FTSE 100 Total Return Index was up 5.7% (last FY down 13.8%). Dividends helped the Australian Accumulation Index to be down 7.5% for the financial year (last FY +27.8%). The S&P 500 Total Return Index took a breather at last – and was down 10.7% (last FY up 36.4%) for the same period. All of these Total Return Indexes include any accumulated dividends, wheras the chart below of the ASX 200 for FY 2022, just shows stock prices.
The ASX 2oo Weekly chart for FY 2022- Dividends helped stem the losses for FY2022, but the ASX Accumulation Index is still down 7.5% for the FY – Incredible Charts – Click for better resolution.
Slack Portfolio Results FY 2022
All Performance results are before tax. The Slack Portfolio is Slack Investor’s investment portfolio and it had its first negative year since its establishment in 2010 – with an annual FY 2022 performance of -14.3%. Full yearly results with benchmarks are shown in the table below. It was a challenging year for all of my benchmarks that were exposed to sharemarkets (Median Balance Fund -2.5%, Vanguard Growth Fund -13.0%, ASX 200 Accumulation -6.5%).
Slack Investor seems to be clueless in real estate predictions … I have thought for some years that there must be a sizable correction soon – as the prices are still stratospheric in Melbourne and Sydney compared to incomes. The correction may still yet happen as interest rate rises are yet to take their toll.
The Brisbane real estate market was the place to be for FY 2022 (+25.6%) on top of a big year last year!) – Inflation was also a suprise for the challenged Slack Investor – with the CPI at +6.1%.
However, the five-year compound annual performance gives me a much better idea about how things are going and will smooth out any dud (or remarkable!) results. The Slack Fund is still ahead of Benchmarks – but currently being challenged by Brisbane Residential real estate.
Slack Investor 5-year compound annual rate of return – compared to benchmarks – Click for better resolution.
The beauty of compounding with a succession of good performance results can be seen in the chart below showing the growth of an initial investment in June 2009 of $10000.
The rate of growth of $10000 invested by Slack Investor in FY 2009 – compared to benchmarks – Click for better resolution.
10-year compound annual rate of return
The Slack Fund has been around a while and, at last, I am generating some long term data (10-year compound “rolling” annual rate of return). Over this time frame, the Slack Fund has been performing very well. A long-term annual rate of return of over 15% – Go Slack Fund!
However, the 10-yr rates of return of the Median Balanced Fund, Vanguard Growth fund, ASX200, and residential property in Brisbane and Melbourne are also great long term investments, generating a 10-year compound annual rate of return of at least 7% p.a.
An “enhanced” satellite view of eastern Australia incorporating an “exaggerated relief” technique to emphasize the topography. The mountains of PNG and Indonesia are on the horizon.
It serves an investor well to occasionally lift themselves away from the day to day stresses of the world – and the trials of owning a share portfolio!
ASX 200 – The Australian Index
My previous post outlined a few of the difficulties of market timing and my decision to be tentatively out of the Australian Index according to my “market timing rules”. I also try not to trade against the market trend … and I would not sell while the weekly chart was looking positive.
So far this has been the case, with the weekly chart just above the rising trend line. I will sell if the ASX200 is below the trend line and still below the stop loss at the end of the week. This gets to one of the problems of market timing – you can set up the most definitive strategy that will give you an objective selling point – but my heart is not in it as Slack Investor believes that the ASX 200 represents reasonable value at the moment. I am actually looking forward to the end of my 20-year market timing experiment – even though it does have the useful purpose of giving Slack Investor something to do in a market downturn.
Lifting the gaze
My absolute favourite way of lifting the gaze is to look at the Vanguard Asset Index chart over a long period. However, a later version than 2021 isn’t due out till mid August 2022 – so I have just shown last years version. The Long term asset class returns chart shown below – in a logarithmic scale, show that the asset classes of Residential Property and Australian shares – are the only really worthwhile games in town. When things just get too much in the day to day trading world – just sit on the couch and gaze in wonder at these two charts … and then perhaps doze off.
Long term Asset returns 1926-2020 – From Stockspot
Extract from the 2021 Vanguard Index chart (Just the 2008-2021 portion) – the dollar values on the right are the results of investing $10000 in index funds in each asset class for 30 years (since July 1991). – Check out the full glory of the Vanguard 2021 PDF chart – Click for better resolution.
I did a north to south crossing of Africa 36 years ago, mostly in a 4-wheel drive truck and, if we stopped in a village, my routine would be to grab the water containers and find a well. This was always a pleasant task as it involved a line-up, sign language and usually a few giggles at the strange visitor’s expense. Overwhelmingly, the well would be attended by women and there was usually an air of joy and strong comradery in the queue.
CSL have just gone to the “well” – with a Share Purchase Plan (SPP). They have purchased a Swiss company, Vifor Pharma (VIFN:SWX), which specialises in iron deficiency and renal disease. The acquisition cost US$11.7 billion and they have already covered most of this with an institutional placement and some new debt. CSL is trying to raise another $750 million from the “well” of shareholders pockets – and they seem likely to get it – let’s hope they will be welcomed back when they need water next time.
It seems to be the way of things that institutions (Brokers and Super Funds) get the first slice … and when this is done, there is a limited offer to retail investors – just to stop them whinging. Most of the time I participate in any share purchase plans as a convenient way to accumulate shares without the cost of brokerage. The CSL offer is set at $273 (or a 2% discount to the share price if CSL shares fall below this mark). Bids for the stock must be lodged by the 7th February, 2022.
“The combination with Vifor Pharma is expected to be financially compelling for our shareholders while expanding and diversifying our revenue base. It is expected to be immediately earnings accretive in the first full year of CSL ownership …”
Nice words Mr Perreault … but I have never ever read a share purchase plan that didn’t offer these comforting sentiments – CEO’s usually love to inform us of their astute decisions. “earnings accretive” just means that after all costs and synergies, the earnings per CSL share (EPS) should go up … and, when earnings go up, the share price should go up.
The projections for acquisitions and mergers are always complicated – the only real proof … will be down the track.
(There is) 30 years of evidence demonstrating that most acquisitions don’t create value for the acquiring company’s shareholders
CSL do have a good track record of acquiring new assets and turning them into future growth engines. However, The CSL offer to acquire Vifor Pharma was generous at 40% above the Vifor list price. But this is where it gets even more complicated, the size of the premium is historically not a good predictor of how the deal will turn out. The most pertinent question is “Has CSL paid more than the acquisition was worth to to CSL.” Slack Investor has no answers yet … We will see how this deal settles.
On 14/01/2022, the CSL share price was $276.00 – A premium of $3.00 to the $273 offer price – or about 1% – so the SPP offer price is no real bargain. Despite Slack Investor’s endless devotion for the company, it seems that the market is currently out of love with CSL.
In the background, despite ongoing problems with plasma collection due to COVID-19, CSL has increased its profit for the past two financial years by 20% – but its share price does not really reflect that. After a rapid increase in 2019, the share price has gone nowhere in the last two years. Macquarie analysts have a 12-month price target on CSL of $338.
Unlike Big Kev, I’m not super excited … The investor presentation, as always, looks compelling – full of talk about global reach, synergies and “developing a significant renal franchise”. But what really impressed me was the confirmation of CSL FY22 NPAT guidance of US$2,150 million – US$2,250 million. This is not advice, even though Slack Investor already has a big holding in this company, he will be participating in a slice of the CSL 2022 SPP.
Scaling Back
One of the annoying things about share purchase plans is the “scaling back”. If the SPP represents a good deal … they are usually oversubscribed. The 2021 Commonwealth Bank (CBA) SPP was such a good deal for retirees that they stumped up $18 billion more than the amount of shares on offer. Their share bids were scaled back by 79.4%. If you applied for $20 000 of CBA, you would have to send off this amount – and you would have been rewarded with $4120 of shares – and then have to wait for your refund.
The CSL 2022 SPP is not as immediately financially rewarding as the CBA offer and will probably not be scaled back as much. CSL has assured share owners that after the SPP, they will at least retaining their percentage shareholding in the company,
Slack Investor has done some rough calculations. As this new placement and SPP represents approximately 5.1% of current CSL ordinary shares on issue -This means that I should be able to buy at least 5.1% of my current holdings in the SPP without the inconvenience of scaling back.
If I owned $120 000 of CSL shares, I would be guaranteed to get at least $6120 (120K x 0.051) in the new SPP without scaling back. I round this up to the nearest allowable dollar value parcel, which is $10000 – and that’s how much I will apply for. Most people would apply for more (up to $30K) – but my portfolio is heavy with CSL, and this scaling back process just annoys me! CSL will of course refund any scaled back monies as soon as practicable after 14/02/2022 – without interest.
