Slack Investor’s in-depth reviews of performance are done at the end of the Australian financial year (30 June) – but a brief look at how things went in calendar year 2019 is in order. It has been a great year for the share investor. Roger Montgomery reports that the Australian All Ordinaries Accumulation Index delivered a return of 24.0% in calendar 2019 – more than double long-term average annual total return. Other World Index yearly changes for 2019 (without dividends) are listed below.
| Indicies | % Change |
|---|---|
| Australian All Ordinaries | 19.10% |
| S&P 500 | 28.90% |
| Nasdaq | 35.20% |
| Nikkei 225 | 18.20% |
| FTSE 100 | 12.10% |
Quality Street
Image from Pointy.com
Slack Investor puts a bit of time into initial stock selection. Before entry to the Slack portfolio, I comb the company universe for high Return on Equity stocks that have low debt and a proven track record of increasing dividends. Delighted to report that a couple of Australian ETF’s have recently emerged that do a similar thing, using parallel principles to the great Benjamin Graham in selecting quality stocks – automatically!
BetaShares Global Quality Leaders ETF – QLTY
QLTY provides access to the 150 highest quality global companies (ex-Australia) based on a combined ranking of four key factors – return on equity, debt-to-capital, cash flow generation ability and earnings stability.
VanEck Vectors MSCI World ex Australia Quality ETF – QUAL
QUAL has a similar objective screening process, to fill its stock register. Companies must have a high return on equity, stable annual earnings growth, and low financial leverage.
There are common elements to the top 10 holdings for each ETF. Companies like Apple, Visa, Facebook and Alphabet feature on both registers. Either of these ETF’s would be a great addition to a portfolio but Slack Investor would lean towards BetaShares QLTY because of their slightly less expensive management costs (0.35% vs 0.40%). Past results indicate there is outperformance attached to this “quality” approach.
My only criticism is that both ETF’s have quality filters that do not seem take into account how expensive the stock is. When Slack Investor researches stocks, I usually dismiss a company if the forecast earnings (+2 years) produce a PE that is over 40. With QUAL and QLTY, it is quality first, regardless of price. I am mollified slightly by the determination that, in the past,
MSCI World Quality Index traditionally has its strongest relative performance during economic downturns
From Van Eck Whitepaper
Sometimes people ask me what stocks to buy – and I seldom have a good answer for them – particularly if they are just starting out on the path of buying shares and their portfolio carries the risk of just one or two stocks. These two ETF’s have given Slack Investor an easy answer.
- Instant Diversification – International exposure
- Access to high growth companies with a good track record of increased earnings
- Rules based stock selection – no ‘active manager’ fees -this should keep expenses low ~ 0.4% … but could be lower!
The early results are not bad either with Morningstar listing one-year performance for 2019 for QUAL and QLTY at 35.8% and 34.5%, respectively.
These sort of products might just put Slack Investor out of a job!