Looking Forward Looking Back … and November 2023 – End of Month Update

Usually not much of a country and Western Fan, but Slack Investor is quite taken with this video of Slim Dusty in his rendition of Looking Forward Looking Back – where two Australian Music Legends (Don Walker and Slim Dusty) combine to make this beautiful Australian song. Slim must have been about 73 when this song was recorded in the year 2000.

Making sense of what I’ve seen
All the love we’ve had between
You and I, along the track
Looking forward, looking back
Looking Forward Looking Back – Don Walker (composer) (1951 – ) & Slim Dusty (vocals) (1924 – 2003)

This song is bitter-sweet to me as it was played at a good friend’s funeral … and I always get a little sad .. but then, I think of the good times I shared with my friend. My friend was also a keen investor and, I’m sure he wouldn’t mind me using this song to launch this post. It is a song of reflection … with a reminder to look forward as well.

Slack Five-Year Individual Share Performance

Though Slack Investor reports on his results on a yearly basis, the annual Nuggets and Stinkers post is a constant reminder of how, in successive years, a company can be “a nugget” … or “a stinker”. The market will often go in trends of overvaluation followed by a period of undervaluation – and the true measure of how the stock has performed is lost in these constant tidal changes. For my purposes (Slack!), a 5-yr measure of performance is about right – as this allows for the true performance of a quality stock to shine through.

I trawled through the Slack Portfolio to find stocks that I had owned for 5 years. I was suprised to find that, of my current 22 individual stocks or ETF’s that I own, I had held only 5 of these for 5 years. This is not what I expected from a Slack Investor and I had to drill down into the portfolio to realize that I had given my portfolio a big shake-up about 4-5 years ago. I had retired, injected a large portion of my work super into my SMSF, and also sold a few stocks to make way for a house purchase.

The 5 stocks that I had 5-yr data on were Altium, Macquarie Group. REA Group, CSL and Codan. The 5-yr Internal Rate of Return (IRR) figures give an “average” annual return for the 5-yr period and include dividends as well as any stock price growth. The results below, for the five years up to 30/06/23, are from my financial software – the free “Sunset” international version of Microsoft Money Australian Version. There are IRR calculators and Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) calculators also available online. I have also included the CAGR Total Return (TR) till 30/06/23 for each of the Slack followed markets (in bold) for reference.

Stock	Symbol	5-yr IRR
Altium Ltd	ALU	14.8
Macquarie Group Ltd	MQG	12.7
S&P500 (TR)		12.2
REA Group Ltd	REA	11.3
CSL Ltd	CSL	8.4
ASX200 (TR)		6.3
FTSE100 (TR)		3.8
Codan Ltd	CDA	3.3

Digesting the above table, Slack Investor is generally pleased with the annual IRR over 5 years of the majority of held stocks. The exception is Codan (CDA) which has had a roller coaster ride in the price charts (see below) – and underperformed the ASX 200 index over 5 years. This stock needs further evaluation to see if I should continue to hold it in the Slack Portfolio.

There are strange days
Full of change on the way
But we’ll be fine, unlike some
I’ll be leaning forward, to see what’s coming
Looking Forward Looking Back – Don Walker (composer) (1951 – ) & Slim Dusty (vocals) (1924 – 2003)

I go to Market Screener Financials page for Codan to quickly see that the income for CDA is projected to increase for the next few years and the company is in a solid financial position. The projected Return on Equity (ROE) remains above 15% and, despite the dramatic price fall during 2021/2022 over earnings downgrades, the companies price trend so far in 2023, has been positive. This holding is currently on “watch” – but I remain a holder of CDA for now.

5-yr Price Chart of Codan (CDA) – from Investing.com

November 2023 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor is IN for Australian index shares, the US Index S&P 500 and the FTSE 100.

Due to a strong rebound this month Slack investor has cancelled his SELL Alert for the ASX200 that started at October 31 2023 due to a stop loss breach – and he now remains IN .

All Slack Investor overseas followed markets had a bumper month. The S&P 500 led the way with a massive rise of +8.9 %. More modest rises for the FTSE 100 +1.6% and the Australian stock market – the ASX 200 +4.5%.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

Alphabet … Google It

Sundar Pichai, the CEO of Google and its parent company Alphabet looks ready to play the “evil genius”.

At around 15% of my investments, Alphabet (US:GOOGL) is a major holding in my portfolio. It is my biggest international holding. I first dipped into the stock back in 2019 and have been trying to top up (in small amounts) each year since.

Since Larry Page and Sergey Brin launched Google in 2004 with a killer search engine, the many tentacles of Google/Alphabet have spread into the everyday life of billions. Youtube alone had 2.6 bn annual users in 2022.

(Google’s search and advertising) is Alphabet’s best business, accounting for 80% of Google’s total revenue in 2022 including Google Search and other properties like Google Network ads and YouTube. The remaining 20% comes from Google Cloud (9.4%) and its apps, hardware and content businesses (10.4%).
From Intelligent Investor

Why keep investing in Alphabet?

Before any investment decision, Slack Investor will do a bit of research. Market Screener has a Financial page on each stock.

When the income chart looks like the above showing a track record of growth (prior to 2023) – and projected further growth up to 2025 – I’m interested. A look now at Slack Investors favourite finance indicators. A projected Return on Assets (ROE) of 24.5 in 2025 (well above 15%), a 2025 predicted PE ratio of 17.5 (very low for a growth stock), and plenty of cash on hand for further aquisitions – it all looks good.

Nitpicking

Despite admiring the skill of Alphabet management in aquisition and company growth, Slack Investor is not enamoured with everything this company does. There are some things that I find annoying. Back in 2017, they sudddenly dropped their popular Google Finance Portfolio feature. Slack Investor then migrated to Yahoo Finance to keep track of his portfolio. I note that Google Finance has recently reinstated its porfolio feature – but I have already moved.

To keep growing revenue, many of their channels are being further monetized. I love using Youtube for music, entertainment, and the millions of helpful “how to” guides. However, the ads at the start of the clips are tedious. This is an attempt to get people into Youtube (no ad) Premium at $13.99 per month.

I also had a recent battle to reduce the amount of data in my google account (Photos, Google Drive, gmail) to below the 15 Gb free limit. This is deliberatly not a simple process and seems to be designed to push people into more storage through a subscription starting at $2.49 per month.

These are relatively small quibbles though – and Slack Investor really doesn’t expect “something for nothing”. I continue to hold and a happy buyer of this company using an international e-broking account with CMC Markets – Alphabet, I hope, will be a very long-term holding.

Buying Shares the Slack Way

The last time Slack Investor wrote about how he buys shares was two years ago, and The Slack Buying Process is worth a read for the detail. I must admit that not much has changed in the method that I use. Two of the shares that I bought back then Alphabet (US:GOOGL) and Betashares NASDAQ 100 (ASX:NDQ) have done OK in that time period, but Coles (ASX:COL) has lagged a bit, but because of dividends, is not on the losing pile yet.

	Buying Price AUG 2021 (AUD)	Current Price SEP 2023 (AUD)
US:GOOGL	$195.45	$214.53
ASX:NDQ	$34.09	$36.28
ASX:COL	$17.94	$15.85

Regardless of these preliminary two-year results, nothing fundamentally has changed for these companies and will stick things out for at least a 5-yr period – and then judge performance.

Since retiring, not much buying and selling goes on in my stable pile. For the investing pile, as I am now mostly a fully-invested “Buy and Hold” type of bloke, I don’t get to buy very often. The only opportunities come when I sell something, or my dividends build up beyond my living expenses.

The first thing to do is get a list of companies that you might be interested in. Slack Investor is an avid reader of the financial press. I get heaps of buying ideas from investment sites such as the AFR, Livewire, Morningstar, ShareCafe, InvestSmart, Motley Fool, etc. I pay particular attention when any articles I read mention “growth”.

Unlike when I am buying fish, for buying shares, I really want to look at the “guts” of a company. For this purpose, my best friend is the excellent Market Screener site. I type in the company name and then look at the Financials Tab. This gives me an overview of what the company has done and what analysts project that a company will do. There are lots of things to look at when evaluating a company – Management team, past performance, level of debt, projected sales, etc. However, if I could boil down a company to its essence with just two financial measures, it would be these two discussed below.

Return on Equity (ROE)

The ROE is usually expressed as a percentage and is the Companies

ROE = Stated Net Income/ Shareholder Equity.

For an instant way to look at whether a company is profitable, they will report a positive ROE. It is an indicator of how well the company uses shareholder funds. If I was getting a 5% return on my money in the bank, my ROE for that investment would be 5%. Obviously a high ROE is good. Slack investor likes his investments to have an ROE of at least 15%.

Sadly, the ROE can sometimes be manipulated by the management team by using a number of tricks. They might use accounting loopholes to distort earnings, or hiding assets off the balance sheet – both of these tricks will inflate the ROE.

As the denominator of the ROE equation is just shareholder equity, it ignores the effect of borrowings. Companies can boost their ROE by taking on large loans (risk). Also, a company with a large cash reserve (desirable for potential take-overs and share buy backs) will be penalised in the ROE calculation.

By screening out companies with large debt and including only companies with a track record of good management,- you can try to mitigate these risks in ROE calculation. Slack Investor is always looking forward, and he likes to use the Projected ROE of Future Income/Shareholder Equity.

Price/Earnings Ratio (PE)

The PE Ratio is defined as a companies share price to its earnings per share.

PE Ratio = Current Share Price/ Current Earnings per Share.

Slack Investor is usually looking at “growth” companies with a relatively high PE Ratio. A high PE ratio could either mean that a company’s stock is overvalued, or that there is an expectation that there might be high growth rates in the future.

By itself, the PE Ratio can be misleading. Sometimes, the earnings of a company can be manipulated through accounting measures and, there is a flaw in this ratio as it does not account for the assets and liabilities of a company.

A PE ratio is best used when compared against similar companies in the same industry or, for a single company across a period of time. Slack Investor usually gets the jitters when the projected PE Ratio is over the 40-50 mark.

Putting it all together

	PE 2026	ROE % 2026
ASX	20	14
CPU	16	33
TNE	38	34
XRO	62	20
SEK	25	11
COH	38	23
RMD	18	22

I put all my possible “growth” stock buying options into a table and used Market screener Financials to get the projected (future) values for PE Ratio and ROE for 2026. I rejected XRO as it was too expensive (PE Ratio greater than 40) and ASX and SEK for low ROE ( <15%). TNE is a great company with good ROE and no debt, but slightly expensive (ROE 38). COH was also slightly expensive (ROE 38).

This left me with CPU (Computershare) and RMD (Resmed). Both good companies with good prospects. Lets have a look at the charts.

For now, Resmed (RMD) seems to be on a downward trend – and Computershare (CPU) on the up. The trend is your friend. This is not advice, but I bought some Computershare on the basis of the above analysis – slightly worried about the debt levels of CPU (which would tend to inflate the ROE), but I bought a small amount and will give this investment 5 years – then re-evaluate.

FY2023 Nuggets and Stinkers and … July 2023 – End of Month Update

“Life is not a bowl full of cherries, there’s good and bad stuff“
Fuzzy Zoeller (American professional golfer)

Fuzzy Zoeller does not always say wise things, but his quote above is on the money. Slack Investor takes the good with the bad.

The trampoline effect of stinkers becoming nuggets in consecutive years reared again, with REA making the transition this year. Also, Nuggets … might end on the Stinker pile the year after. Slack Investor puts more emphasis on growth over a multi-year period, but compiles the yearly Nuggets and Stinkers list …. because its fun!

Growth stocks (usually high Return on Equity (ROE >15%), as with other stocks, often have cycles of price – bouts of overvaluation followed by a period of undervaluation.

The percentage yearly returns quoted in this post include costs (brokerage) but, the returns are before tax. This raw figure can then be compared with other investment returns. I use the incredibly useful Market Screener to analyze the financial data from each company and extract the predicted 2o25 Price/Earnings (PE) Ratio, Dividend Yield, and Return on Equity (ROE), on the companies below. This excellent site allows free access (up to a daily limit) to their analyst’s data, on the financials tab for each stock, once you register with an email address.

Slack Investor Stinkers – FY 2023

Financial year 2023 was a welcome recovery in the technology sectors. All of Slack Investors followed markets Australia, the UK and the US having gains over the financial year 2023. However, Slack Investor is always ready for lessons in humility and still managed to pick up a few stinkers along the way.

Integral Diagnostics (IDX) -19% (Sold Oct 2022)

(IDX – 2025: PE 18, Yield 3.8%, ROE 10%) Integral Diagnostics provides medical imaging services at a number of urban and regional locations in Australia and New Zealand. This company was also one of my stinkers last year (FY2022 -39%) The sinking feeling that I got during my monthly chart reviews was just too much … and I finally gave into that negative energy in October 2022 – and sold. This, unfortunately, turned out to be the bottom of the market – and IDX has made a modest recovery since.

Computershare (CPU) -18% (Sold May 2023)

(CPU– 2025: PE 16, Yield 3.8%, ROE 29%) Computershare is well known to owners of some Australian shares as they run the registry for many Australian companies. It started as an Australian technology business in 1978 and since has become a major global player in financial services. Slack Investor just bought at a bad time … and I sold in May 2023 to make another share purchase. CPU seems to be a solid global business though – Will look at buying this one again.

Dicker Data (DDR) -18% (Still held)

(DDR – 2025: PE 14, Yield 6.8%, ROE 42%) Dicker Data is the only Australian owned and ASX-listed major IT provider. It is a hardware, software and cloud distributor for most of the well known US IT companies (Microsoft, Cisco, HP, etc). The business is projected to continue to grow and, as the share price seems to have “bottomed out”, Slack Investor will continue to hold on because of the companies excellent projected PE, Yield, and ROE.

BetaShares Asia Technology Tigers ETF -7% (Sold Sep 2022)

(ASIA – 2023: PE 17, Yield 2.6%,) Growth in Asia … What could go wrong! Plenty it seems. These “technology tigers” that make up this ETF have been part of a global selloff of tech-related shares in Asia since 2021 as many US investors take flight from the China market due to US/China tensions.

This company was also one of my stinkers last year (FY2022 -33%) and was “on watch” during my monthly chart reviews. Sadly, the pain became too much and I unloaded near the bottom of the market again … and, it has since made a modest recovery. I have maintained at least some exposure to the Asian tech sector with with Vanguard FTSE Asia ex Japan ETF (VGE.ASX).

Slack Investor Nuggets – FY 2023

Nuggets made a comeback this Financial Year. Slack Investor continues to invest in high Return on Equity (ROE) companies with a track record of increasing earnings, Companies with these qualities sometimes behave as “golden nuggets”.

Technology One (TNE) +48%

(TNE – 2025: PE 37, Yield 1.5%, ROE 34%) This Software as a Service (SaaS) and consulting company continues to be profitable. This great business was also a nugget last year (+17%). A high 2025 PE of 37 (Expensive) is a little scary but, if the high Returns on Equity (34%) remain, on balance, this is OK. I found this company through the writings of Rudi Filapek-Vandyck – a great Australian Investor and writer, when he talks, Slack Investor listens.

Altium (ALU) +40%

(ALU – 2025: PE 34, Yield 2.3%, ROE 32%) Altium is an Australian based developer and seller of computer software for the design of electronic products worldwide. It focuses on electronics design systems for 3D printed circuit board (PCB) design. Slack Investor has part-owned this business since 2009 and has enjoyed the increasing value that ALU has created. This sector is very now … and remains a favourite of Slack Investor.

CarSales.com (CAR) +37%

(CAR – 2025: PE 28, Yield 3.0%, ROE 10%) CarSales.com is the go to for selling cars, boats and other vehicles. It does, in an efficient way, what the classified ads used to do. I have noticed that the Return on Equity is dropping (Now 10%) and will keep this company on watch – but I cant argue with the recent price rises.

BetaShare NASDAQ 100 ETF (NDQ) +36%

(NDQ – 2023: PE 26, Yield 1.0%) Exposure to the powerhouse of US Tech companies with the simplicity of an ASX ETF. Management fees are reasonable at 0.48% – Slack Investor remains a fan.

Pro Medicus (PME) +36%

(PME – 2025: PE 78, Yield 0.6%, ROE 46%) Pro Medicus is a developer and supplier of healthcare imaging software and services to hospitals and diagnostic imaging groups. Slack Investor actually met the CEO and co-founder of Pro Medicus, Dr Sam Hupert, at an investment seminar last year. His modesty, US foothold, and debt-free approach to expanding his business impressed me – I’m obviously glad I bought in – but the very high PE ratio (+78) is worrying – expensive.

REA Group (REA) +30%

(REA – 2025: PE 39, Yield 1.5%, ROE 29%) Like Carsales.com, REA has dominated the space left by the old newspaper classifieds in selling real estate in Australia. REA has expanded into India and other global locations. A high PE ratio (39) but while projected Return on Equity (ROE) remains high (29%), this is OK.

VanEck Wide Moat ETF (MOAT) +30%

(MOAT – 2023: PE 19, Yield 2.6%,) The Wide Moat ETF run by VanEck is a rules-based selection of “attractively priced US companies with sustainable competitive advantages” Sounds good doesn’t it. The management expense ratio of 0.49% is OK for such curated US exposure.

Slack Investor Total SMSF performance – FY 2023 and July 2023 end of Month Update

After a difficult 2022, FY 2023 is described by J. P. Morgan as being “kinder to balanced portfolios”. True That! The growth stocks that were punished last year bounced back strongly. In the Australian superannuation scene, the median growth fund (61 to 80% in growth assets) returned +9.2% for FY 2023. The ASX 200 chart shows a gradual climb for the financial year.

ASX 200 Weekly chart for FY 2023 – From Incredible Charts

After a tough FY 2022, the FY 2023 Slack Investor preliminary total SMSF performance looks like returning to form and coming in at around +18%. The 5-yr performance is a more useful benchmark to me – as it takes out the bouncing around of yearly returns. At the end of FY 2023, the Slack Portfolio has a compounding 5-yr annual return of around 10%.

The new financial year started of positively for Slack Investor markets. The ASX 200 + 2.9%; FTSE 100 +2.2%; and S&P 500 +3.1%. He remains IN for all index positions.

All Index pages (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index) and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes.

Advice for a young man … and June 2023 – End of Month Update

I was recently delighted when my 14-yr old nephew asked me what I thought he should invest in with his earnings from his part-time jobs.

Firstly, it is a compliment to an old bloke to be asked anything, and secondly, it is testament to the financial maturity of this fine young man that he would be thinking about the world of the share market while still at school.

If he was older and in a steady full-time job I would advise he automate his savings as much as possible and lash into index funds via a platform such as Stockspot, Pearler, Vanguard Personal, or Raiz)

His first investment would be in the order of a few thousand hard-earned dollars from part-time jobs. It is vital that the investment has good prospects and unlikely to lose money over a 5-yr period (no guarantees though!). Given that he would not feel the need to access the money for 5 years (hopefully longer!)

For a first investment, I would add the criteria that it should be a well-known Australian company that might appear in the news occasionally and remind him that he is a part-owner … and an investor!

If he was already 18, it would be “off to the races” and we would immediately set up a broker account in his own name and he would begin to experience the magic of being a shareholder. Being under 18 complicates things a little as minors are not allowed to directly own shares- we need to enlist his parent’s help.

If the parent already has a broker account the best way to start is for the parent to buy the shares on his behalf. When he turns 18, my nephew can start his own account with a broker (e.g. Self Wealth, Commsec, Pearler) and the parent can use an off-market transfer (get the form from the broker) to get the shares into my nephew’s hands as a “gift” including any dividends earned. During this brief holding period, any dividends and any capital gain will count as taxable income in the parents name – but this is a small price to pay to tap my nephew’s enthusiasm.

Alternatively, you could open a broker account in their name (as the trustee for “Nephews name”). The process is a little more complicated and is explained in detail by SelfWealth.

The Nuts and Bolts of Stock Selection

Naturally, I would address this problem in a methodical way and set up a list of Slack owned companies – I couldn’t recommend a company that I didn’t own myself. Some of my favourite stock metrics are gathered from the excellent Market Screener site on the financials page for each stock.

My number one metric for looking at companies is their Return on Equity (ROE), estimated for the year 2024 – Slack Investor is looking forward. This gives me an idea about whether a company is making an investment dollar grow. Higher the better, I start getting curious about a company when ROE is above 15%.

The projected Price Earnings ratio in 2024 is next – I don’t like the P/E Ratio to get above 40, as this indicates the current price of the company is 40 times its earnings (expensive) – but some exceptions are made if the company is growing fast (High ROE). The yield (dividend) is not that important to a young investor, it is the total growth that counts.

Stock	Symbol	2024 ROE	2024 P/E	2024 Yield	Price 30/06/23	% Price below consensus
CSL Ltd	CSL	18%	30	1.5%	$277.38	-18%
Wesfarmers	WES	30%	22	3.9%	$49.34	Fair Value
Coles	COL	31%	22	3.9%	$18.42	Fair Value
Altium	ALU	32%	41	1.9%	$36.92	-6%
Macquarie Bank	MQG	13%	14	4.2%	$177.62	-10%
Car Sales	CAR	10%	28	2.8%	$23.82	-3%
RealEstate.com	REA	29%	41	1.3%	$143.03	-7%

Analysis of some Slack Investor owned stocks using the projected Return on Equity (2024 ROE); price earnings ratio in 2024 (2024 P/E); 2024 Yield; and the current price (30 June 2023); and current discount from the average analyst perceived value – marketscreener.com – Financials Tab

Looking at the figures, even though the stock price of CSL hasn’t really gone anywhere in the last 3 years, it would be my first pick as it is currently 18% below its fair value price (by a consensus of analysts). It is such a strong Australian company that really thinks of the future by continuing to increase its spend on research and development each year.

Wesfarmers (Bunnings, K-Mart, Officeworks, etc) and Coles look OK too because of their high Return on Equity (ROE) – they also have the benefit that you can continually pop in to see how your business is going. Altium has languished in price this last few years but remains a great company for the future – if my nephew was interested in the “tech” space.

This isn’t advice, Unless, of course, you are my nephew!

June 2023 – End of Month Update

The financial year closes and looking at the 12-month charts for FY 2023 – Slack Investor concludes … “It was better than last year”!

Slack Investor remains IN far all followed markets. The ASX 200 (+1.6%) and FTSE 100 (+1.1%) drifted slightly upward for the month. It is boom-time in the US with the S&P 500 rising 6.5%. The US index had moved more than 15% above its stop loss, so I have moved the stop loss upward to 4048.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index). The quarterly updates to the Slack Portfolio have also been completed.

Imperfections in the Brickwork and … December 2022 – End of Month Update

Detail from the Pen and Ink “Behind Armstrong Street Shops” – the remarkably talented Bren Luke, 2022.

Slack Investor is always on the lookout for new investments … and nothing attracts the jaundiced Slack Eye more quickly than continuous long term results.

Brickworks Ltd (BKW:ASX) have just had their AGM presentation. I was very impressed by the claim that they have maintained, or increased, normal dividends for the last 46 years!

Dividend record – Brickworks 2022 AGM presentation – Brickworks

Tracking the share price of BWK:ASX since 1968 – Brickworks 2022 AGM presentation – Brickworks

As well as being a very good maker of bricks, Brickworks operates as an investment company and own a 26.1% stake of the diversified investing house Washington H. Soul Pattinson (SOL:ASX). SOL, in turn have holdings in

TPG Telecom – Australian telecommunications provider
Brickworks Limited – Clay and concrete production for the construction industry
New Hope Group – Coal and oil mining and energy generation
Tuas Limited – Telecommunications provider
Apex Healthcare Berhard – Malaysia-based pharmaceutical production
Pengana Capital Group Limited – Fund management
Aeris Resources – Mining and exploration activities

Now Slack Investor does not want to get all preachy here, as as everyone has to draw their own line in the sand – These things are very subjective. I looked up New Hope Mining on the excellent Morningstar Sustainalytics site to get an idea on how well the company is ranked in terms of Environment Sustainability and Governance (ESG).

ESG Risk rating for New Hope Corp. Ltd. – from Sustainalytics

New Hope Group ranked 14571 out of 15559 in terms of ESG risk rating – on a worldwide basis. I personally would feel uncomfortable being a part owner of a thermal coal miner given the current state of the planet.

So despite the most excellent management and performance of BWK, while they still own an interest in the New Hope Group, I will look elsewhere for investments.

Puff Puff MOAT

On the subject of digging deep, I have been a long term holder of the VanEck Morningstar Wide Moat ETF (MOAT:ASX). Slack investor has many vices – Wine and beer just being just two of them … so again, I won’t lecture – as these things are very personal. However, some of the sins that my mother rubbed into me as being “particularly evil” are smoking and gambling. I will do my best to avoid ownership of these type of stocks in deference to my dear Mum.

I noticed back in 2021 that this MOAT ETF had Phillip Morris International as one of its top 10 holdings. According to the Yahoo Finance site – Phillip Morris is 2.5% of the MOAT holdings! Owning a part of a multinational tobacco company that is a leading part of Big Tobacco didn’t really sit well with Slack Investor.

According to the Global Burden of Disease Study, in 2015 alone, smoking caused more than one in ten deaths worldwide and killed more than 6 million people, resulting in a global loss of nearly 150 million disability-adjusted life-years
The Lancet

Slack Investor marked MOAT as an ETF to get rid of, despite liking the concept of its construction – “companies with sustainable competitive advantages”. I had a feeble attempt at shareholder activism and emailed VanEck about this … and enquired whether thy might screen the MOAT ETF with an ethical filter … to get rid of tobacco and gambling stocks – they replied with a polite “no”.

Modified (to protect the innocent!) email from VanEck to Slack Investor

I finally got around to attempt to sell MOAT this month and I thought I should just check the VanEck holdings MOAT site and look at their complete holdings list. Lo and behold … at 29/12/2022, Phillip Morris has now gone from their holdings list! So, for now, MOAT is a keeper!

If at a loose end during the holidays and need a distraction, Slack Investor highly recommends the free exhibition “Streets of Your Town” at the Ballarat Art Gallery, VIC. Bren Luke is an amazing artist, his exhibition runs till 5th Feb 2023.

December 2022 – End of Month Update

The year closes and, I’m not sure if Slack Investor was naughty (probably?)… but, there was no “Santa Rally” this month. All followed markets took a dive in December. The ASX 200 down 3.4%, the FTSE 100 down 1.6%, and the S&P 500 down 5.9%,

Due to the return of all followed share markets to more normal valuations, I have returned my stop-loss upper-limits to 15%. This means that when I work out my stop loss value, I add another 15% to it, this is my upper limit. If the stock price exceeds the upper limit, I will adjust my stop loss upwards. This method helps to lock in some gains if they occur.

Slack Investor remains IN for the FTSE 100, the ASX 200, and the US Index S&P 500.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index). The quarterly updates to the Slack Portfolio have also been completed.

Finding Value … and October 2022 – End of Month Update

In amongst the general carnage of the market, Slack Investor has been doing a little buying. An opportunity came up with an existing holding. Dicker Data (DDR). DDR is an Australian-based technology hardware, software and cloud distributor.

From time to time, a company will go to institutions and shareholders to raise a bit of working capital using a Share Purchase Plan (SPP). Dicker Data (DDR) needed to expand its warehouse facilities. Fair enough – but does Slack Investor want to part with more cash to invest in this company? Lets take a fresh look using the excellent Market Screener Financials Page. The Slack “basics” of a high return on equity (38.7% in 2022) and projected growth – on top of an established period of growth – are still intact – Tick

DDR – Historical (Black)and analyst projected income growth (grey) till 2024 – Market Screener

The price of DDR has been generally “beaten up” in the last 6 months as interest rates have risen and growth stocks have suffered. There are probably some more tough times ahead … but Slack Investor likes to take the “long view”. This business has a long term growth strategy and will probably persevere despite current headwinds – Tick.

DDR – Analyst projected PE ratio till 2024 – Market Screener

The current DDR Price/Earnings ratio is 22.9 – below recent values and projected to reduce further as income increases. – Tick.

Although analyst predictions can be wrong, on balance, the miserly Slack Investor was happy to part with a few dollars in this Share Purchase Plan as he could find some value in this business. There is every prospect that the DDR share price will increase in the next few years.

Finding Index value using CAPE

As with individual companies, the whole share market will oscillate betwee overvalued and undervalued. Slack Investor has written about the Cyclically Adjusted Price to Earnings ratios (CAPE) which use ten-year average inflation-adjusted earnings to take out some of some of the volatility of annual earnings. By plotting this CAPE over a period of time, we can look at how the whole sharemarket is currently valued in terms of historical data.

Using monthly CAPE data from Barclays, the 40-yr mean is calculated and plotted together with the CAPE values. A “fair value” zone is created in green where the CAPE is within one standard deviation of the mean.

Historic CAPE ratios for ASX 200 – From 1982 to September 2022

Historic CAPE ratios for FTSE 100 – From 1982 to September 2022

Historic CAPE ratios for S&P 500 – From 1982 to September 2022

From the above, The ASX 200 (7% below av.) and the FTSE 100 (13% below av.) are “On Special” at the moment as their CAPE values are below their long-term averages. Even the S&P500, after a long 2-yr period of being “Over valued”, is now getting close to being “Fair valued”.

October 2022 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor remains IN for Australian index shares though it is still on watch after breaching its stop loss at the end of September 2022.

My last post described how I had left the UK and US Index in the middle of October 2022. I am now back IN to the US Index – and, for the moment, OUT of the UK Index. Although, I am keeping a weekly watch on the FTSE 100 in case there is a signal to return to the market.

This month illustrates why I feel glad that my 20-yr index timing experiment is coming to an end in 2024. After exiting the US and UK markets only 2 weeks ago, there has been a rally in both the US Index S&P 500 and (to a lesser extent) the FTSE 100. The momentum has been sufficient for Slack Investor to be “whip-sawed” back into the US Index on a weekly buy signal – I am starting to get “really over” this timing the market experiment.

For the experiment, Slack Investor uses a trend following (or momentum) system called the Directional Movement Index. The buy signal shows itself as a downward dip in the ADX (grey line) of the lower panel below. There are many ways of setting up this system. Slack Investor likes the “smoothing” that is enabled by a system that looks back over the previous 11 periods – but the complexities are best left for the Resources page.

*S&P 500 Weekly chart showing* a BUY signal on the Directional movement Index *weekly chart. The weekly price ranges are at the top and Average Directional Movement Index (ADX) patterns below – From* Incredible Charts

This month, there are positive movements all round. The ASX 200 +6.0%, the FTSE 100 +1.6% and the S&P 500 +8.0%.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

FY2022 Nuggets and Stinkers and … July 2022 – End of Month Update

“So the last shall be first, and the first last: for many be called, but few chosen“
Matthew 20:16 – King James Version of the Christian Bible

Slack Investor is not a very religious person – but he is a numbers man and 84% of the global population identifies with a religious group – so I have to go with the flow here. This sort of majority demands respect. The Christian disciple Matthew was reporting on one of Jesus’s teachings. Biblical scholars think that Jesus was trying to point out that Heaven’s value system is far different from earth’s value system.

The “Last first and First last” might also be applied to how some of the Slack Portfolio stocks have been going over consecutive years. There seems to by a cycle of last years Nuggets … might end on the Stinker pile the year after – and vice-versa. Growth stocks have many virtues … but they are not immune to the cycles of price – bouts of overvaluation followed by a period of undervaluation.

The percentage yearly returns quoted in this post include costs (brokerage) but, the returns are before tax. This raw figure can then be compared with other investment returns. I use Market Screener to analyze the financial data from each company and extract the predicted 2024/2o25 Return on Equity (ROE), Dividend Yield and Price/Earnings (PE) Ratio on the companies below. This excellent site allows free access (up to a daily limit) to their analysts data once you register with an email address.

Slack Investor Stinkers – FY 2022

Financial year 2022 was the Pepé Le Pew of all of Stinktown for Slack Investor.I hold mostly growth shares in the technology and healthcare sectors. These sectors have been heavily punished across the world so far in 2022.

This is the first time I have had a negative result for my investments over a financial year since 2009. Slack Investor is a great believer in long term investing returns – usually evaluated over a 5-year period – so this year’s result, while painful, does not change my overall strategy.

Three of my “stinkers” this year were actually “nuggets” from last year. For FY 2020, Codan +161%, REA +59% and IDX +37%. Such is the cyclic nature of some growth stocks.

Codan (CDA) -58% (Still held)

(CDA – 2025: PE 14, Yield 3.8%, ROE 25%) Codan is a technology company that specializes in communications and metal detecting. This company was one of my big nuggets last year (+161%) – so I should not have been really surprised that there could have a bit of a pullback. The decline hurt, but the fundamentals of the company remain sound. Holding on.

Xero (XRO) -41% (Sold)

(XRO– 2025: PE 81, Yield 0.3%, ROE 15%) Xero is an innovative cloud -based accounting provider for small business. Every business owner that Slack Investor talks to say that Xero is a boon to their business. This sort of “word of mouth” got me over-excited this year and I just held my nose and jumped in – against all my rules of avoiding the excessively high forward PE ratios of over 50! It is these high PE companies that are usually punished first in a downturn – and that’s exactly what happened. I still look at it and think its a decent growing business – but I can feel the recent bite!

Integral Diagnostics (IDX) – 39% (Still held)

(IDX – 2024: PE 16, Yield 4.5%, ROE 12%) This medical image company provides diagnostic image services to GP’s and specialists. IDX was another of my nuggets from last year (+37%) that has just shed all of last years gains. The Return on Equity of this company is starting to get a bit low (<15%) – But the PE and yield seem OK. Will keep this company on watch for the moment.

BetaShares Asia Technology Tigers ETF -33% (Still held)

(ASIA – 2022: PE 14, Yield 0.7%,) Growth in Asia … What could go wrong! Plenty it seems.

These “technology tigers” that make up this ETF have been part of a global selloff of tech-related shares this year.

A lot of the Chinese companies (such as Alibaba) have been marked down because the Chinese government imposed its will on a few industries. Also the US government has hinted at action on Chinese companies that have listed on American market. However, the ASIA ETF has large holdings in such monsters as Taiwan Semiconductors, Samsung and Tencent Holdings – so I will accept the current pain and stick with this as a long-term holding

REA Group (REA) -33% (Still held)

(REA – 2024: PE 29, Yield 1.8%, ROE 32%) The owners of RealEstate.com.au. which is the go to portal for house selling and buying. 65% of Australia’s adult population are checking the site every month looking at property listings and home prices. Another long-term holding.

I have only listed the stinkers that lost over 30% this year … sadly, there were many more rogues that lost over 15% for the Slack Fund. They include PPK Group (PPK) -28%; Altium (ALU) -25%; Nick Scali (NCK)-20%; Pushpay Holdings (PPH)-16%; and A2 Milk (A2M)-15%.

Slack Investor Nuggets – FY 2021

Nuggets were few and far between this year. A great benefit of investing in companies that have a high Return on Equity (ROE), and with a track record of increasing earnings, is that they sometimes behave as “golden nuggets”.

Technology One(TNE) +17%

(TNE – 2025: PE 34, Yield 1.7%, ROE 36%) This Software as a Service (SaaS) and consulting company continues to be profitable. This year is the 13th year in a row of record half-yearly profits. A high 2025 PE of 34 (Expensive) is a little scary but, if the high Returns on Equity (36%) remain, on balance, this is OK.

Macquarie Group (MQG) +10%

(MQG – 2025: PE 25, Yield 4.0%, ROE 13%) Macquarie is a complex business with a range of banking and financial services, and plays in global markets and asset management. Once again, the management seem to know what they are doing – Slack Investor remains a fan.

Honourable mention to the only other company that ended in the black – Coles (COL) a decent +8% in these troubled times.

Slack Investor Total SMSF performance – FY 2022 and July 2022 end of Month Update

In a year that Chant West describes as “a rough year for markets”. Following FY2021, which was one of the strongest years for Super funds (+18% for FY21), things have now lurched south with the median growth fund (61 to 80% in growth assets) returning -3.3% for FY22.

The FY 2022 Slack Investor preliminary total SMSF performance looks like coming in at around -14%. However, the 5-yr performance is a more useful benchmark to me – as it takes out the bouncing around of yearly returns. At the end of FY 2022, the Slack Portfolio has a compounding 5-yr annual return of over 13%.

Despite a breach of the stop loss for the ASX 200 last month, Slack Investor remains tentatively IN for Australian index shares on a dramatic rise of 5.7% this month. The FTSE 100 also had a good month (+3.5%)and I remain IN. The US Index S&P 500 eclipsed them all with a remarkable 9.1% gain – and I am now a BUY back IN.

Last month the ASX 200 price went below its stop loss. Slack Investor tries not to exit a stock against the momentum of the market, so I have been off the couch and closely watching the ASX 200. It has remained above the rising trend line and emerged above the monthly stop loss. I am tentatively still IN.

ASX 200 Weekly chart – From Incredible Charts

After a sell, it is important to have a notion when to get back IN to an Index or a stock. When trend trading, my main tool for finding a buy signal is a trend following (or momentum) system called the Directional Movement Index. There are many ways of setting up this system. Slack Investor likes the “smoothing” that is enabled by a system that looks back over the previous 11 periods – but the complexities are best left for the Resources page.

In addition to the BUY signal from the Directional Movement Index for the S&P 500, the charts show a triggering of the “Wedgie” pattern where the stock price breaks through a long term down-trend. This reinforces the BUY.

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

Trading in troubled times … and January 2022 – End of Month Update

nature, waves, lighthouse, landscape, Portugal, heavy, wind, HD wallpaper

It is worth revisiting corrections, these annoying dips in the market are testing – even for experienced investors.

A correction is a 10% or greater decline in the stock market in a short period of time. The average rally period without a correction is 357 trading days, according to a Deutsche Bank analysis of stock market moves since the 1950’s.
CNN Business

As there are about 250 trading days in a year and Slack Investor is hoping for a 50-year investing career (50 x 250 / 357 )= 35 . That’s a lot of corrections … so I had better have a plan on how to handle them.

Despite recent rallies in the last few trading days – In January 2022, there was a technical “correction” in both the US and Australian markets.

The S&P 500 index dipped into “correction” territory on Monday for the first time since March 2020. The benchmark fell 10% or more from its recent high in early January, before a late-day rally.
Greg Iacurci – CNBC – Jan 25, 2022

Most corrections solve themselves. A 2018 Goldman Sachs report found that the average correction for the S&P 500 lasted only four months. In the 40 years prior to 2020, the S&P 500 experienced 17 corrections – only a third of them resulted in the larger falls associated with bear markets.

This is not an exact science – but when a correction occurs, I try to think about the scenario where a correction will turn into something worse.

As most bear markets are associated with a recession – Are the economic conditions are such that a recession is likely? – Is this current correction likely to lead to a “bear market”?

The Omicron COVID-19 variant has showed that it is difficult to project into the future. However, even though some industries are suffering, while interest rates remain low and there seems to be some signs of economic recovery. I will try to shut out the “noise” this time.

Index stocks – S&P 500, ASX 200, FTSE 100

I am running a personal 20-yr experiment using “stop losses” to try to time the market for index funds, rather than “buy and hold”. The results so far can be found on the index pages of this blog (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index). The annual gains using this timing method have been modest so far with outperformance of +1.5%, +1.9% and -0.3% , respectively. The jury is still out on this experiment and a full report will be given in 2024.

For the bulk of my holdings – do nothing

For most of my stocks, I take no action during these corrections. Most of my portfolio contains individual companies that I have built up a history with, and I am mostly convinced of their viability and growth outlook for the next 5-10 years. For these companies, I am comfortable to ride the stock price up … and down – this is something I accept about owning stocks. For example, although getting out of the US Index last week, I am happy to keep my holding of US Alphabet stock (GOOGL) – for many reasons.

Tinker with the stocks that you are not so sure about

There is a second-tier in my stock portfolio that includes my theme ETF’s and other companies that I am not so totally convinced about – or, I have changed my mind about their growth prospects. A correction is a good time to review these stocks.

With shares, the market decides what “it thinks” that your stock is worth on a minute by minute basis. This stock price can vary a lot on a daily basis – but over a longer period, the stock price should be decided by more fundamental levers such as earnings, amount of debt, quality of management, and growth potential.

January 2022 – End of Month Update

Slack Investor is off the couch and sold his US Index shares. He remains IN for Australian index shares (only just!) and the FTSE 100.

A bit of turbulence in the markets this month. The ASX 200 and S&P 500 dipped into correction territory briefly. At the end of the month, the Australian Index had a monthly fall of 6.4% and the US Index, down 5.3%. The FTSE 100 was a relative star +1.1%. Slack Investor remains watchful.

On Monday 24 January, (New York time) I sold my US Index shares at the S&P equivalent of 4332. This was below the previous days closing price (4397) … but I have to accept the possibility of a bit of “sell shrinkage” on the next day – in this case 1.5%. However, for consistency. I have used the closing price on the previous week for my calculations.

Despite the end of month rally in S&P 500 price (Jan 31 4515) – I am glad to out of the US Index as I have been troubled by the high valuations for some time. Slack Investor would not have the foresight to get out right at the top of the market. In the spirit of “trying to get things mostly right” I am happy with the US Index trade – a gain of 55.4% over 19 months.

As a way of “zooming out” to get an idea of how current prices are in relation to long term trends – I have updated my Cyclically Adjusted Price to Earnings ratios (CAPE) to include December 2021 data for the S&P 500. Despite it’s limitations, CAPE is still Slack Investor’s best way of assessing quickly whether a market index is under or over-valued compared to its long term average.

At the end of 2021, the S&P 500 was still 61% above its 40-yr average! This is in contrast to the ASX 200 (14% above average) and the FTSE 100 (about average). When valuations get this far out of kilter, for the US Index, my assessment is that there is much more downside risk than upside. The recent breach of the stop loss on a weekly basis gave me an excuse to get out of this broad index.

CAPE ratios for the S&P 500 from January 1982 till December 2021

All Index pages and charts have been updated to reflect the monthly changes – (ASX Index, UK Index, US Index).

CSL Goes to the Well – Share Purchase Plan 2022

I did a north to south crossing of Africa 36 years ago, mostly in a 4-wheel drive truck and, if we stopped in a village, my routine would be to grab the water containers and find a well. This was always a pleasant task as it involved a line-up, sign language and usually a few giggles at the strange visitor’s expense. Overwhelmingly, the well would be attended by women and there was usually an air of joy and strong comradery in the queue.

CSL have just gone to the “well” – with a Share Purchase Plan (SPP). They have purchased a Swiss company, Vifor Pharma (VIFN:SWX), which specialises in iron deficiency and renal disease. The acquisition cost US$11.7 billion and they have already covered most of this with an institutional placement and some new debt. CSL is trying to raise another $750 million from the “well” of shareholders pockets – and they seem likely to get it – let’s hope they will be welcomed back when they need water next time.

It seems to be the way of things that institutions (Brokers and Super Funds) get the first slice … and when this is done, there is a limited offer to retail investors – just to stop them whinging. Most of the time I participate in any share purchase plans as a convenient way to accumulate shares without the cost of brokerage. The CSL offer is set at $273 (or a 2% discount to the share price if CSL shares fall below this mark). Bids for the stock must be lodged by the 7th February, 2022.

“The combination with Vifor Pharma is expected to be financially compelling for our shareholders while expanding and diversifying our revenue base. It is expected to be immediately earnings accretive in the first full year of CSL ownership …”
Paul Perreault, Chief Executive Officer and Managing Director of CSL

Nice words Mr Perreault … but I have never ever read a share purchase plan that didn’t offer these comforting sentiments – CEO’s usually love to inform us of their astute decisions. “earnings accretive” just means that after all costs and synergies, the earnings per CSL share (EPS) should go up … and, when earnings go up, the share price should go up.

The projections for acquisitions and mergers are always complicated – the only real proof … will be down the track.

(There is) 30 years of evidence demonstrating that most acquisitions don’t create value for the acquiring company’s shareholders
Harvard Business Review

CSL do have a good track record of acquiring new assets and turning them into future growth engines. However, The CSL offer to acquire Vifor Pharma was generous at 40% above the Vifor list price. But this is where it gets even more complicated, the size of the premium is historically not a good predictor of how the deal will turn out. The most pertinent question is “Has CSL paid more than the acquisition was worth to to CSL.” Slack Investor has no answers yet … We will see how this deal settles.

On 14/01/2022, the CSL share price was $276.00 – A premium of $3.00 to the $273 offer price – or about 1% – so the SPP offer price is no real bargain. Despite Slack Investor’s endless devotion for the company, it seems that the market is currently out of love with CSL.

In the background, despite ongoing problems with plasma collection due to COVID-19, CSL has increased its profit for the past two financial years by 20% – but its share price does not really reflect that. After a rapid increase in 2019, the share price has gone nowhere in the last two years. Macquarie analysts have a 12-month price target on CSL of $338.

CSL Share price over the last 3 years – From marketscreener.com

Unlike Big Kev, I’m not super excited … The investor presentation, as always, looks compelling – full of talk about global reach, synergies and “developing a significant renal franchise”. But what really impressed me was the confirmation of CSL FY22 NPAT guidance of US$2,150 million – US$2,250 million. This is not advice, even though Slack Investor already has a big holding in this company, he will be participating in a slice of the CSL 2022 SPP.

Scaling Back

One of the annoying things about share purchase plans is the “scaling back”. If the SPP represents a good deal … they are usually oversubscribed. The 2021 Commonwealth Bank (CBA) SPP was such a good deal for retirees that they stumped up $18 billion more than the amount of shares on offer. Their share bids were scaled back by 79.4%. If you applied for $20 000 of CBA, you would have to send off this amount – and you would have been rewarded with $4120 of shares – and then have to wait for your refund.

The CSL 2022 SPP is not as immediately financially rewarding as the CBA offer and will probably not be scaled back as much. CSL has assured share owners that after the SPP, they will at least retaining their percentage shareholding in the company,

Slack Investor has done some rough calculations. As this new placement and SPP represents approximately 5.1% of current CSL ordinary shares on issue -This means that I should be able to buy at least 5.1% of my current holdings in the SPP without the inconvenience of scaling back.

If I owned $120 000 of CSL shares, I would be guaranteed to get at least $6120 (120K x 0.051) in the new SPP without scaling back. I round this up to the nearest allowable dollar value parcel, which is $10000 – and that’s how much I will apply for. Most people would apply for more (up to $30K) – but my portfolio is heavy with CSL, and this scaling back process just annoys me! CSL will of course refund any scaled back monies as soon as practicable after 14/02/2022 – without interest.